Connect with us

Magazine

Why a heat pump doesn’t always lower your bill, says Jordi Martí

Technical architect Jordi Martí warns that replacing your boiler doesn’t guarantee a much lower bill.

Published

on

Instalación de bomba de calor en el interior de una casa

Image: alpha innotec / Pexels

According to technical architect Jordi Martí, “in theory” a heat pump should divide consumption “by three or by four”, but when you look at the bills, “you don’t notice it as much”. An energy-saving expert, Martí warns in a video on his TikTok channel that replacing a gas boiler with this system does not by itself guarantee a much lower bill: there may be barely any difference.

Martí does not question the appliance. He says it is “almost magic, a revolutionary invention”, but argues that it needs the right conditions to perform well. According to him, when you switch from a gas boiler and radiators to a heat pump, comfort sometimes fails to arrive.

The expectations, not the appliance

For Martí, the problem is not that the heat pump works badly, but that the user’s expectations do not match the conditions of the home. He sums it up with humour: “It’s not you, it’s me; I mean, it’s not her, it’s you. It’s your expectations”.

His underlying idea is that, in his words:

“A heat pump does best when you ask little of it, when it’s a house, and when it’s well insulated”.

With a well-insulated house and little demand, he adds, consumption is “very, very small”, and the principle is the same if the pump is air-source.

The example of Kilian Jornet and the pianos

To illustrate it, Martí turns to the Catalan mountain runner Kilian Jornet, a leading figure in trail running. “Kilian Jornet will get you up Everest in no time with brutal efficiency, but if you make him carry pianos he probably won’t stand out much”, he says.

The comparison applies to poorly insulated homes. In Martí’s words: “If you have a poorly insulated home with normal radiators and you want to replace the boiler with a heat pump, it will be like making him carry pianos”. His conclusion is that everyone shines when the conditions are right, and that what the heat pump wants is to run calmly, without being asked for a lot of power.

Insulation and windows, key to consumption

Martí considers insulation one of the factors with the greatest influence on consumption. A house that retains heat well needs less energy and lets the unit work at low power for longer. If, on the other hand, it has poor insulation, old windows or many losses, the appliance has to run for considerably longer. That is why two homes with the same unit can end up with very different consumption.

Old or leaky windows cause constant heat loss. One of the first measures to correct this is to replace them with double or triple glazed windows.

Underfloor heating or conventional radiators

The type of heat emitter also matters. Underfloor heating works with water at a lower temperature and suits a heat pump well, whereas conventional radiators may need higher temperatures. According to Martí, if the radiators require high temperatures, the heat pump loses its advantage.

What to check before removing the boiler

Before dismantling the boiler, it is worth checking the condition of the home and assessing whether it is time to improve the insulation or replace the oldest windows, so that the pump has to supply less energy. The OCU, in its guide to preparing your home, points out that the level of insulation affects the efficiency of the heat pump, so replacing the boiler and leaving everything else unchanged is not always enough.

This article contains affiliate links: if you buy through them, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. More information.

Most read